- Sally eats an apple.
- It eats an apple.
- Her eats an apple.
- They eats an apple.
- She eats an apple.
In the second sentence, Sally is replaced by “it.” Does this make sense? In general, it is not a good idea to replace a noun that is a person using “it” because “it” is gender neutral. If Sally was a horse, for example, then this sentence might make sense – but let’s assume Sally is a person. In this case, this second sentence is incorrect.
In the third sentence, Sally is replaced by “her.” Sally is the subject of the sentence, and therefore it has to be replaced by a nominative pronoun. “Her” is not a nominative pronoun - so this sentence does not make grammatical sense. However, if someone said this sentence to you, you might understand what the speaker was saying. You would at least infer correctly that the person the speaker is talking about is female.
In the fourth sentence, we have used “they” to replace Sally. Does this example make sense? In fact, it does not. This is because Sally is a singular noun – we are only talking about one person. This means that we need to use a singular pronoun to replace the word Sally. “They” is a plural pronoun. Even though it is in fact nominative in case, it is not the right number, and therefore, this sentence is incorrect.
The final sentence, the fifth sentence, is the correct one: Sally is properly replaced by a singular, nominative pronoun.